Artist recommendation

Phil Collins – He could be loud. And he could be quiet.

By Michael Buller

AI-created cover with drums and a seated singer in warm stage light, and the name Phil Collins.

Cover artwork created with AI.

My first memory of Phil Collins is ‘In the Air Tonight’. That song was simply different. Dark, full of tension, with that slow build – and then the drums came in. It felt as though everyone liked it back then. I certainly did.

And yet I lost touch with his music for quite a while. During my apprenticeship, a colleague was a huge Phil Collins fan and owned all his records. I hadn’t really found my way into his music yet. Looking back, I have to smile: she was clearly a few years ahead of me.

I really rediscovered him through Serious Hits… Live!, released in 1990. I already owned some of his records, including …But Seriously, which I bought when it came out. But that live album opened another door. The energy, the band, his presence. That was when I began to understand just how good he was.

A Londoner with drums and acting in his blood

Philip David Charles Collins was born on 30 January 1951 in London. He began playing drums as a child. His mother worked as a theatrical agent, and he appeared on stage early too, playing the Artful Dodger in the London musical Oliver!. That resourceful little street kid fits rather well with the mischievous character I later saw in his videos and film roles.

He now lives in Switzerland again, by Lake Geneva. But his story reaches far beyond the singer we know from the radio: actor, drummer, songwriter, producer – and, for many years, both a solo artist and a member of one of Britain’s most successful bands.

Genesis: from behind the drums to the microphone

Collins joined Genesis as their drummer in 1970. There is a lovely story about his audition: while the other candidates played inside the Gabriel family home, he waited in the swimming pool and listened. By the time his turn came, he already knew a little of the material. Apparently his clever streak wasn’t invented for the videos.

When Peter Gabriel left in 1975, Genesis initially searched for a new singer. In the end, Collins took over himself. A Trick of the Tail, released in 1976, was the first Genesis album with him handling all the lead vocals. Over time, the progressive rock band also became a band with enormous pop hits: ‘Follow You Follow Me’, ‘Mama’, ‘Invisible Touch’, ‘Land of Confusion’, ‘No Son of Mine’ and ‘I Can’t Dance’.

His solo career did not immediately replace Genesis. The two ran alongside each other. And anyone who mainly knows Collins as a pop singer should also listen to his work with jazz-rock band Brand X. There is a remarkably agile, inventive drummer to discover there.

‘In the Air Tonight’ – the tension before the drums

His first solo album, Face Value, arrived in 1981. ‘In the Air Tonight’ opened it with an atmosphere that remains unmistakable. Its darkness gave rise to a story about someone watching a man drown without helping. That story is a myth, which Collins himself has rejected. The song grew out of the difficult period surrounding the end of his first marriage, giving his anger and disappointment an outlet. Its lyrics do not tell a clearly defined crime story.

The sound has a story too. During recordings with Peter Gabriel, Collins and engineer Hugh Padgham discovered the heavily compressed room sound with an abruptly cut-off reverb that became famous as ‘gated reverb’. It had already appeared on Gabriel’s ‘Intruder’. ‘In the Air Tonight’ turned it into an event for a huge audience.

My tip is the live recording on the deluxe edition of Face Value. I love its slow build. You can hear the tension grow, the space the song leaves – and how much more powerful that makes the arrival of the drums. There is so much else to discover on this record too, including quieter songs such as ‘If Leaving Me Is Easy’.

The songs that almost everyone recognises

‘Sussudio’, with its insistent groove. ‘One More Night’, longing for another chance. ‘Against All Odds’, making the emptiness after a separation feel immediate. Or ‘Another Day in Paradise’ from …But Seriously: a song about homelessness and how easily we overlook other people’s suffering. These weren’t minor radio moments. These songs were everywhere.

Then there was ‘You Can’t Hurry Love’, his salute to the Supremes and the Motown sound, the duet ‘Easy Lover’ with Philip Bailey, and ‘I Wish It Would Rain Down’ with Eric Clapton on guitar. Anyone who thinks they only know one or two Phil Collins songs usually discovers quite quickly that they know rather more.

One track I find particularly powerful in terms of sound is ‘I Don’t Care Anymore’ on Hello, I Must Be Going!. Those heavy drums, the hardness, the determination. There is nothing soothing about it. To me, it sounds like someone who has had enough and is drawing a line.

‘Both Sides’ – one of his best albums for me

For all his power and volume, his quieter side moves me just as much. Both Sides, released in 1993, is one of his best albums for me. It contains so many wonderful songs that can easily disappear behind the familiar hits.

Collins wrote and produced the album himself and played every instrument, recording it in his home studio. Perhaps that explains some of its intimacy: you hear a person who needs to say something, rather than a grand star production.

‘Both Sides of the Story’ asks us to consider another perspective. ‘Can’t Turn Back the Years’ and ‘Everyday’ deal with love, loss and trying to carry on. And then there is ‘There’s a Place for Us’. One of my favourite songs of his. It still gives me goosebumps. For me, it holds that longing for a shared place where a love might still be possible.

This is an album I would make time for, from beginning to end. Phil Collins could be loud. But he could also be quiet and deeply moving.

That mischievous face on screen

I always enjoyed watching his videos too. He often had that look, as if he knew a little more than everyone else. To me, he was the mischievous character who somehow stayed one step ahead.

‘In the Air Tonight’ is inseparable from the famous night drive in the Miami Vice pilot: Crockett and Tubbs, the road, the lights, that music. Collins later appeared in the episode ‘Phil the Shill’, playing a shady con man himself. It suited him remarkably well.

In 1988, he played train robber Buster Edwards in Buster. Its soundtrack includes ‘Two Hearts’ and his version of ‘A Groovy Kind of Love’. Tarzan brought him into a very different film world in 1999. ‘You’ll Be in My Heart’ won him an Oscar in 2000. He recorded the songs for several language versions himself, including German. Brother Bear followed later. His music often finds you long before you consciously put on one of his albums.

Three concerts – and one evening that stays with me

I have seen Phil Collins live three times: in Munich’s Olympiahalle in 1997, at the Olympiastadion on 6 June 2004, and finally at Cologne’s RheinEnergieStadion in 2019. The first two belong to the ‘Trip into the Light’ and ‘First Final Farewell’ tours. Rediscovering him through Serious Hits… Live! had started a connection that lasted for years.

Cologne was different. Collins had to sing sitting down. Back problems, operations and nerve damage had severely limited his mobility and his ability to play drums. His son Nic was now behind the drum kit.

It was sad to see him that way. The physically agile, mischievous performer of earlier years was no longer there. But as soon as he sang, I felt that connection again. His voice and the songs still had their power; his magic still reached me. That is how I remember the evening: a wonderful concert, even though it hurt to see what he could no longer do physically.

My view of the stage at Phil Collins’s Cologne concert in 2019.
Cologne, 2019. Photo: Michael Buller.

Nic Collins: much more than just the son

Nic Collins says he started playing drums at the age of three. Among his earliest formative memories is watching his father’s 2004 tour. I like the thought of him being there as a child and later taking his own place behind that drum kit. I don’t know whether he was there on my particular night in Munich, though.

At 16, he joined his father’s world tour in 2017. Later he also played on the final Genesis tour and with Mike + The Mechanics. With Better Strangers, he is working on his own music. He has long been building a musical path of his own.

Alongside his father, he names John Bonham, Stewart Copeland and Taylor Hawkins among his influences. I find it interesting that he works out so much by ear. To see the talent and energy he brings to the drums, find him on Instagram as @nic_collins.

‘Take Me Home’ – that farewell at the end

And then there is ‘Take Me Home’. For me, this song belongs at the end of a Phil Collins concert. Singing together, slowly letting go after an evening full of music. It was his closing song – a moment I usually found especially emotional.

You can experience it again on Serious Hits… Live!, including the edition reissued in 2019. The original album dates from 1990. Seeing 2019 beside it on a streaming service does not make it a recording from his final solo tour. That distinction matters. For me, it remains one of those live albums that brings some of the connection between an artist and an audience home with you.

My personal recommendation

What stays with me

Phil Collins is one of those musicians I knew for a long time before I really discovered him. First that extraordinary song on the radio. Then the colleague with her records. Later Serious Hits… Live! and three concerts of my own.

Today I hear more than the big hits. I hear the force of ‘I Don’t Care Anymore’, the tension of ‘In the Air Tonight’ and the vulnerability of Both Sides. And ‘There’s a Place for Us’ still gives me goosebumps.

That is how I will remember him: the mischievous performer with incredible energy. And the man on a chair who could still reach me in a stadium full of people.

He could be loud. He could be quiet. And both could go straight to the heart.

Sources and further reading

Phil Collins – official website · In the Air Tonight: Collins on writing the song · The drum sound: Collins and Hugh Padgham · Both Sides: recording and reissue · Disney: music and film · Nic Collins interview, April 2026 · Home in Switzerland, February 2026 · Health: 2026 interview report · Munich 1997 tour archive · 2004 tour archive · Cologne 2019: venue archive · Miami Vice: music and guest appearance

Artist of the week

How this music sounds

Genres
Pop · Rock · Soul · Progressive rock · Jazz fusion
Listening moods
Energy · Emotion & goosebumps
Sound & instruments
Vocals · Drums · Percussion · Keyboards · Guitars · Bass · Horns
Language
Mainly English; Disney recordings also in other languages

Discography

Phil Collins & Genesis: album discography

Original studio and live albums, compilations, box sets, soundtracks and selected EPs. Genesis also includes albums without Phil Collins, clearly labelled. Brand X: six albums featuring Collins. Reissues are grouped with the original release. Singles, video releases, unofficial releases and regional repackagings are not catalogued here.

BBC BroadcastsGenesis · archive recordings 1970–1998Box set
The Last Domino?GenesisCompilation
Remixed SidesPhil CollinsRemix album
Other SidesPhil CollinsCompilation
Plays Well with OthersPhil CollinsCompilation
The SinglesPhil CollinsCompilation
Take a Look at Me Now…Phil CollinsBox set
R-KiveGenesis · includes solo recordings by band membersCompilation
Going BackPhil CollinsStudio album
Genesis Live 1973–2007GenesisBox set
Genesis 1970–1975GenesisBox set
Live over Europe 2007GenesisLive album
Genesis 1983–1998GenesisBox set
Genesis 1976–1982GenesisBox set
Tarzan: The Broadway MusicalOriginal Broadway Cast / music: Phil CollinsMusical
The Platinum CollectionPhil CollinsBox set
Platinum CollectionGenesisCompilation
Love Songs: A Compilation… Old and NewPhil CollinsCompilation
Brother BearPhil Collins / Mark Mancina✓ In this portrait →Soundtrack
TestifyPhil CollinsStudio album
Genesis Archive #2 1976–92GenesisBox set
Turn It On Again: The HitsGenesisCompilation
TarzanPhil Collins / Mark Mancina✓ In this portrait →Soundtrack
A Hot Night in ParisThe Phil Collins Big BandLive album
…HitsPhil CollinsCompilation
Genesis Archive 1967–75GenesisBox set
Calling All StationsGenesis · without Phil Collins; vocals: Ray WilsonStudio album
Dance into the LightPhil CollinsStudio album
Live from the Board: Official BootlegPhil Collins & The Indescribable DinEditions: 2024 RSD reissueLive EP
The Way We Walk, Volume Two: The LongsGenesisLive album
Both SidesPhil CollinsEditions: 2016 Deluxe · 2024 All the Sides✓ In this portrait →Studio album
The Way We Walk, Volume One: The ShortsGenesisLive album
We Can’t DanceGenesisStudio album
Turn It On Again: Best of ’81–’83GenesisCompilation
Serious Hits… Live!Phil CollinsEditions: 2019 Remaster✓ In this portrait →Live album
…But SeriouslyPhil Collins✓ In this portrait →Studio album
BusterVarious Artists / Phil Collins✓ In this portrait →Soundtrack
12″ersPhil CollinsRemix album
Invisible TouchGenesisStudio album
White NightsVarious Artists / Phil CollinsSoundtrack
No Jacket RequiredPhil Collins✓ In this portrait →Studio album
Against All OddsVarious Artists / Phil CollinsSoundtrack
GenesisGenesisStudio album
Three Sides LiveGenesisLive album
Is There Anything About?Brand XStudio album
Hello, I Must Be Going!Phil Collins✓ In this portrait →Studio album
3×3GenesisEP
Face ValuePhil CollinsEditions: 2016 Deluxe · 2026 Full Value✓ In this portrait →Studio album
AbacabGenesisStudio album
DukeGenesisStudio album
Do They Hurt?Brand XStudio album
ProductBrand XStudio album
…And Then There Were Three…GenesisStudio album
Spot the PigeonGenesisEP
Seconds OutGenesisLive album
Moroccan RollBrand XStudio album
LivestockBrand XLive album
Wind & WutheringGenesisStudio album
Unorthodox BehaviourBrand XStudio album
A Trick of the TailGenesis✓ In this portrait →Studio album
Genesis Collection Volume TwoGenesisBox set
Genesis Collection Volume OneGenesisBox set
The Lamb Lies Down on BroadwayGenesisEditions: 2025 50th AnniversaryStudio album
Selling England by the PoundGenesisStudio album
Genesis LiveGenesisLive album
FoxtrotGenesisStudio album
Nursery CrymeGenesisStudio album
TrespassGenesis · without Phil CollinsStudio album
From Genesis to RevelationGenesis · without Phil CollinsStudio album
Ark 2Flaming YouthStudio album

70 researched releases

Researched 13 November 2026. Years refer to original releases. Soundtracks and cast recordings contain other performers; Collins’s involvement does not make them solo studio albums. This discography was researched to the best of our knowledge. It may be incomplete or contain individual errors. Corrections and additions are welcome.

Sources and editions: Phil Collins · Genesis · Brand X · Phil Collins / Discogs

What will you read next?

Your thoughts on the music

What music, story or listening experience would you like to share? I would love to hear your thoughts.

Comments appear only after I have personally reviewed and approved them. Spam, advertising, abusive or unlawful contributions will not be published and will be removed. Your email address will not be displayed publicly. Privacy policy.

Your thoughts on the story

I personally review comments before publication. Your email address will not be displayed publicly.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Klanggeschichten is my hobby. I receive no commission, use no affiliate links and earn nothing from these recommendations.